Thursday, November 19, 2026

Film Microreview: Allen

‘80s nostalgia will ruin your life

A barely hidden tragedy lurks inside every cute adventure involving children. Once you’ve saved the hidden fantasy kingdom, or helped the stranded fairy/mermaid/unicorn find its way back home, or rescued the lost princess, or averted the death of magic, what next? How can mundane life possibly hope to compare? After having met elves and wizards and dragons, it must feel like a cosmic punishment to have to deal with job interviews and dentist appointments and taxes. You better hope the amount of excitement in your life doesn’t peak when you’re ten.

So consider poor Elliott at the end of E.T. What’s he going to do with the rest of his life, now that he’s had the most world-shaking experience in the history of the human species? What kind of man will he become? What will maintain his interest for long enough? The cruel truth is that, if he wants to have anything resembling a meaningful stay on Earth, the best thing he can do is forget about his alien friend.

In the Netflix movie Allen, the child who had an alien friend turns out to be unable to grow up. The break from reality is brief, but profound by a child’s standards: the alien and the human watch movies, eat junk food, play board games. But then, as always happens, the alien needs to return to its planet. And the child doesn’t take that well, not one bit. Entirely understandably, he spends the next decades of his life obsessed with recapturing the original spark that gave his life a fleeting sense of transcendence. He refuses to move out of his childhood home, just in case the alien decides to come back, and builds a makeshift radio to try to communicate with it. While the people around him are getting engaged and/or having kids, he remains stuck in a bygone time.

Although Allen is written and directed as a comedy, watching an adult willingly trap himself in a hopeless quest to stop time and feel like a child again is just sad. There are heart-rending moments in this movie when you can tell how completely that alien encounter messed him up: he sees no reason to take up any earthly pursuit because he’s genuinely convinced that this world has nothing to offer him.

Allen ought to serve as an antidote to ‘80s nostalgia. We’re living through a massive cultural whiplash in which some members of Generation X struggle with letting the past be past. The kids who grew up with Ghostbusters and He-Man and Star Wars and Top Gun and Mad Max and, yes, E.T. have become furiously possessive over the joys of their childhood, desperate to keep any future iteration of those stories feeling just like they felt the first time. No mature adult should want the Reagan years to come back, but nostalgia isn’t rational. Nostalgia is a coward’s refuge when reality takes effort.

In a twist that isn’t given enough time to fully deliver its punch, the alien in Allen does come back. The grownup human and his unchanged wrinkly gray pal immediately resume their unfinished business with amusement rides and cotton candy and karaoke, because that’s the limit of what our protagonist can imagine he can do with an emissary from another star: very human things he could have done with anyone else at any time. However, soon we learn that the alien isn’t on Earth for innocent reasons, and the second half of the movie shifts gears to a race against time to prevent a messy, horrifying, planet-wide, very yucky catastrophe. Turns out ‘80s nostalgia can kill you, literally.

Allen is a story that knows how to perform at the scale of its modest ambitions. It shouldn’t be a big revelation that all children need to grow up. It shouldn’t take a tongue-in-cheek deconstruction of one of the most cherished classics of cinema to explain why time can’t go back. But will the former kids listen? It must still be possible to reach some, to save some. Don’t lament the past that went by, that no longer exists and can’t hear you. Lament the present that isn’t being lived.

Nerd Coefficient: 7/10.

POSTED BY: Arturo Serrano, multiclass Trekkie/Whovian/Moonie/Miraculer, accumulating experience points for still more obsessions.

Film Review: Ebenezer

More horror, less Christmas in the latest adaptation of the Dickens classic

Some stories are eternal, not just in a philosophical sense but in a practical, movie industry, goldmine sense. Much like Romeo and Juliet and Cinderella, A Christmas Carol is the kind of story that has countless adaptations, almost such that it’s become a genre unto itself. The approach to the story and the style of each adaptation becomes a reflection of its society. In keeping with the recent trends for smart horror, the latest adaptation of A Christmas Carol is Ebenezer, a film that is more creepy horror and less colorful cozy Christmas. With leading actors like Johnny Depp and Trammell Tillman, that edginess should be no surprise.

Ebenezer tells the classic story of Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp), who is running his financial business alone after the death of his partner Marley (Ian McKellan) seven years ago. He is aided in his work by his hardworking clerk, Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint), whom he mistreats and underpays. Cratchit is struggling to support his wife (Charlie Murphy) and children, including his terminally ill youngest child (Freddie Lee-Grey). Scrooge scoffs at efforts to help the poor and ignores the request of his nephew Fred (Sam Claflin) for Scrooge to spend time with Fred and his wife Clara (Daisy Ridley). On Christmas Eve, Scrooge is visited by the ghost of his old partner Marley, who warns him to change his ways and tells Scrooge of the impending visits of the ghosts of Christmas past (Andrea Riseborough), present (Trammell Tillman), and future. Through the course of the night, each ghost takes Ebenezer on a tour of his life and the lives of those he neglects. Seeing the troubled course of his life and seeing the suffering of others helps to teach him a lesson in kindness.

Instead of opulent Victorian Christmas scenes, Ebenezer takes a deep dive into the macabre, both through the supernatural and also through the horror of real-world neglect and poverty. More than other adaptations, Ebenezer spends time pondering extreme poverty in a world where the poorest are forced into prisons and workhouses. The opening credits montage alternates between scenes of the wealthy and scenes of the poor in complementary situations. Many adaptations of the story mention the existence of workhouses, but this one actually spends time there, painting them in the same grim, gray melancholy as the ghost-filled graveyard scenes.

Another unexpected element is the film’s decidedly supernatural tone. I’ve watched several other versions of this story, and this one is very horror forward. The palette is gray and dark. The buildings are creepy and gothic. But beyond that, there are direct horror elements, including throngs of zombie-like ghosts coming after Ebenezer. At one point he gets sucked into his bed in a scene reminiscent of the only Nightmare on Elm Street film I’ve watched. In other versions of this story, the ghosts of Christmas past and present are portrayed as essentially (although eccentrically) human, but in this film, they are quite creepy and inhuman despite the fact that they were once, tragically, regular people. Bill Murray’s 1988 version of the story, Scrooged, had some extreme horror special effects but was balanced by equally extreme humor. Ebenezer mostly stays grim and serious rather than veering into true comedy.

Ebenezer benefits from the built-in witty banter it takes from the original text. However, the awkward attempts at physical humor were my least favorite parts of the film. The strange choices were unsettling. In some ways they added to the overall feeling of dread rather than offering a counterbalancing lightness. Of course, that kind of strange humor is perfect for an actor like Johnny Depp. Unlike other versions of Ebenezer Scrooge, his interpretation feels more quirky and eccentric rather than just grumpy and stingy, and the result is jarringly unhinged. In addition to elements of horror, the film adds unexpected cynicism. Some of the traditionally honorable side characters are portrayed as hypocritical con artists. Even a beggar in an early scene turns out not to be what he seems to be. The message seems to be that trust is elusive, even as we strive to do better. All this bleakness somewhat dampens the film’s emotional intensity. But in the scenes where it does connect, the effect is solid.

Ebenezer closely tracks the story beats and even some of the dialogue of the original text, but it periodically diverges from it in unexpected ways. Part of the fun of watching a retelling is knowing generally what will happen next but being surprised at the execution. In Ebenezer there are enough small changes that you start to have a feeling of uncertainty, although the primary story beats remain the same. One interesting divergence from the usual interpretations is the spirits themselves. Normally, they are portrayed as sort of like angels with a job to educate. However, in Ebenezer the three spirits (past, present, and future) are noted to be formerly real living people who are now doing penance in their death for their own shortcomings in life. This adds some unexpected poignancy and creepiness to the story.

Overall, the tone of Ebenezer is closer to quirky stories like Widow’s Bay, offering grimness and horror as a way to process difficult realities. This style may not work for those looking for big Christmas trees and happily singing children. Despite its general faithfulness to the original story, Ebenezer is a grim departure from the usual optimism, and offers an edgier version of Scrooge for a new generation of viewers.

Nerd Coefficient: 7/10.

Highlights:

  • More horror, less Christmas
  • Strange humor
  • Edgier, cynical storytelling

POSTED BY: Ann Michelle Harris – Multitasking, fiction writing Trekkie currently dreaming of her next beach vacation.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Book Review: As We Fall Through Time by Claire North

Worlds enough and time?

[Note: There some light spoilers in this review. I avoid large ones, or anything substantial further than 20% into the book.]

Claire North is simply incapable of writing a bad novel. From their early work under their birth name (Catherine Webb), to their excellent urban fantasy as Kate Griffin and the huge stylistic and thematic sweep of work under their current moniker (ranging from Homeric historicals through LeCarre pastiche through space opera), they have produced a couple of dozen novels which bottom out at “really good.” On top of this extremely high base, the best of their oeuvre is as good as any speculative fiction produced over the past twenty years. Last year’s space opera-meets-thumpingly unsubtle jeremiad against climate inaction and late capitalism, Slow Gods, was top tier North (and shortlisted for the LeGuin Prize), and As We Fall Through Time is, remarkably, operating at the same level. It will, I’m sure, end up being one of the best novels I read this year.

Having just said that North’s work spans a wide range of themes and subgenres, I do think their most common mode seems to be the speculative thriller, using a key speculative premise to set up very well-crafted, often character-driven, action. After departing from that space with Slow Gods and their previous Songs of Penelope trilogy, they return to more typical territory in As We Fall Through Time. The key speculative premise here is that some very few people are born in circumstances where they might never have existed had the proverbial butterfly flapped its wings at a slightly different time. These people both do and no not exist in permanent quantum superposition, and as a side effect are able to slip through time via buildings or terrain which exist both in their current time and in the time to which they wish to travel.

Our protagonist is Cal, a time traveller whose gender is as fluid as their place in the timestream (as with the neurodiverse protagonist of Slow Gods, this reads somewhat as North working through something about themself in fiction). The inciting incident is a hookup: in Paris looking for an object with unusual temporal qualities in the early days of the French Revolution, Cal (male at this point) runs into a solider named Olivier and ends up going home with him. This one-night stand, basically accidentally, expands to genuine affection and eventually a long-standing, loving relationship. Olivier resolutely refuses to ask too many questions about the interventions Cal makes to keep him alive, from mysterious pills when he is ill (antibiotics fetched from the 21st century) to completely implausible appearances from Cal to save Olivier while he’s off on military campaigns during the Napoleonic Wars. And Cal keeps using his time travel abilities to make such interventions, up to and including ones which deny someone he loves a fair bit of agency.

[This paragraph is where a spoiler for 20% in is discussed, so skip this paragraph if you're sensitive to such.] The bold choice the book makes is that, about 1/5 the way through, Olivier runs out of rope despite Cal’s heroic efforts. One day, Cal comes home and Olivier has been erased from the timeline: not dead, but never existed. I hasten to add that, in a book about time travellers where playing with causality and paradox are major themes, this erasure, while of course devastating to Cal, is not something they take lying down, nor is it necessarily the end of their story with Olivier. Cal’s struggle to understand what happened to his husband—and another paradox-implicating murder a fellow time traveller asks them to investigate—kickstarts the plot into full gear. At first glance I read this narrative choice as a gender-flipped version of the classic girlfriend fridging to motivate the main character. But as I read more, as Cal’s grief kept piling up and their time traveler colleagues never quite manage to understand it or who Olivier was to them, I realised North was perhaps doing something more clever and far more devastating: literalising the very real phenomenon of queer couples and queer domesticity being (figuratively) erased from history. This sort of thing from historians is well known enough that there is a meme about it: “they seem to be very good friends.” But it also happens outside the bounds of formal written history: it was distressingly common for queer couples through the mid 20th century to have their photos, their letters, the record of their lives together burned to ashes by homophobic families after their deaths. In As We Fall Through Time, Cal has had this done to his relationship with Olivier by time itself. Read in this way, much of the book is almost unbearably moving, particularly because North never descends to the maudlin.

Once these murder mystery plots get going, it becomes clear the book is doing quite a lot of things, all very well, in a short page count. As Cal investigates how a particular body appeared in Seoul at a particular time—and where Olivier might have gone—we also get something of an out-of-order Bildungsroman subplot for them, with various elements of their backstory and future playing out and explaining how the compelling character we see at the start of the novel came into being. We also slowly see an eco-thriller strand become central to the story: it turns out climate change is, directly or indirectly, going to lead to the extinction of humanity within 500 years or so. If you’re a time traveller, of course you’re going to try to convince people to change course at some point before it becomes too late to do so, and maybe those efforts will have some unforeseen consequences of their own.

In tone and approach, As We Fall Through Time reminds me of one of my favourite earlier North books, The Gameshouse (originally a trilogy of ebook novellas). As with the supernatural gamblers in The Gameshouse, the time travellers in this novel are hidden agents behind the scenes playing in history. Some are merely playing; idle immortals looking to hang out with John Lennon or sleep with Cleopatra and the like. Some use their powers to enrich themselves, and some try to shift events in ways they’d prefer. But in a way The Gameshouse really didn’t (it was huge fun, but to my mind didn’t have a clear normative take on the amoral games it depicted beyond a slight anarchic streak), North here is clearly contemptuous of the shits that treat history as their private playground. They’re also incandescently furious about the selfishness inherent in the choices over decades that have led to runaway climate change. Late in the novel, Fadimatu, one of Cal’s time travelling colleagues and a historian, says, “What is history, Cal, if not the story of people choosing, every day, in every single moment, and then living with the consequences? We should live with consequences. Living without is what makes people cruel.” Impunity, more than anything else, stands condemned.

Oddly enough, given this book is actually about climate change, it is not as unsubtle and occasionally on the nose as Slow Gods was with the same themes; the narrative has earned that explicit statement by the time North has Fadimatu say it. The tone is ultimately fatalistic but not hopeless. Threading that needle is no easy task, and it’s an illustration of North’s fine touch as a writer that they manage it (the ripped from the headlines anti-AI drive-bys, despite me entirely agreeing with the sentiment, are somewhat less successful).

All of this is delivered in prose that is incisive and interesting at the sentence level and extremely effective in using missing and non-standard punctuation, line breaks, and page layout to convey the disconnection and dislocation as the narrative slips through time. Techniques like these risk coming across as too-clever games, but in North’s hand they come across as correct and inevitable. The narration is also hugely characterful, an omniscient first person that, it becomes clear as the narrative develops, is actually a person who has been witness to the events of the novel, a dangling question for the reader that eventually is answered with the most audacious flourish; I actually cackled out loud when I worked out what they were doing. The whole thing is a hell of a ride, and while you don’t always know where you’re going, you can trust that Claire North, as per usual, is taking you somewhere far more interesting than most.

Highlights:

  • Weaves multiple plot threads together into a hugely satisfying narrative
  • Brilliantly written with vivid narration
  • A love story, to its time-twisted core

Nerd coefficient: 8/10.

Reference: North, Claire. As We Fall Through Time [Orbit, 2026].

POSTED BY: Eddie Clark. Professional nerd by day, amateur nerd by night. @dreddieclark.bsky.social

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Book Review: Hokey Pokey by Kate Mascarenhas

 Cannibal cryptid psychoanalysis, for your reading pleasure

Judging from the reviews of this book on Storygraph, it suffers not from any lack of quality (TL;DR: it’s fantastic and I loved it so, so much) but from a severe case of mismarketing, and that is deeply unfortunate. Let me set things straight right now:

It is not a murder mystery in an art-deco era hotel in Birmingham.

It is not a story of two women entangled with the same man coming to value each other, with queerness and mutual support as each learns that the man is a worthless waste of space.

It is not a feminist tale about a woman struggling to build professional careers, hampered by early 20th-century sexism in the medical profession.

It is not a tale of a woman who has rebuilt herself after a catastrophic childhood mistake revealed the depths of her family’s fucked-upedness, only to be forced to face the consequences of that mistake decades later.

All of these things are core elements of the book, yes. Absolutely these things happen. Already you can tell that this book is rich and layered, and invites the reader to engage in multiple conversations that would make for a very effective literary historical fiction tale. But if you went into this book expecting such a thing, you would be very, very surprised to discover that it is not this at all. Because—whoof, my goodness, this is a book in which deeply messed up people embrace their messiness with a whole-hearted self-awareness that leaves you simultaneously appalled, impressed, and rooting for them.

Our main character, Dr. Nora Dickinson, is a psychoanalyst, based in Europe, but visiting the Regent Hotel, Birmingham, because her ex-lover Leo (also a psychoanalyst) has asked her to spy on his wife Berenice, who he suspects is cheating on him. Nora has an uncanny ability to remember and repeat people’s words and voices with perfect fidelity, and for this reason makes a good spy: her reports are undeniably accurate, and Leo—an utter fucker—quite likes her ability to imitate Berenice’s voice. Nora, a smart lady who knows what she wants, for some baffling reason wants Leo, so she agrees to assist him on his quest. If she can find evidence of Berenice’s infidelity, she reasons, Leo will drop Berenice. Furthermore, the more she observes Berenice, the better she can imitate her, which Leo likes, because he is gross. The end goal is that Leo will take Nora as the newer, better version of Berenice, one who can imitate her exactly in voice and mannerism, but who will be devoted and faithful.

Like, ew, right? Both unfair to Berenice, but also wildly unhealthy on Nora’s part. You’d think a psychoanalyst—and a skilled one, at that—would be able to recognize all the problems with this plan. But Nora simply doesn’t think about it in that way. And—something I really appreciated—the narrative itself doesn’t particularly care about whether this train of reasoning is healthy or unhealthy. That’s not what this book is about. We are given a character with a particular set of abilities, a well defined goal, and a focused determination to achieve that goal, and we are relieved of the moral obligation to have opinions about the rightness or wrongness of this state of affairs.

This is so freeing in a narrative! It is the psychological equivalent of a rogue vigilante deploying self-defined justice, beating up bystanders until they tell him what he wants to know, stealing cars, shooting everyone he suspects of being a baddie, unbothered with due process or the possibility that he’s murdering innocent people. Yes, of course Jack Reacher is bad news, but we all love him, right? This is that. This is just like that.

But this is not only that. Because shortly after Nora arrives at the Regent Hotel, a heavy snowfall paralyses Birmingham, trains are cancelled, and no one can get anywhere easily except on foot (well—there is one other exception, but I won’t spoil that). So when guests and staff start disappearing, and people begin reporting strange creatures appearing in their rooms, the narrative shifts from a psychological, personal narrative about Nora’s plans for her future into something that much more resembles a monster flick—a monster flick which turns out to be intimately connected with all sorts of gruesome details about Nora’s past. Don’t worry, though. Oddly, this book is not in the slightest bit scary, because, of all the people in this story, Nora herself is an extremely competent protagonist, and is well equipped to take care of the bloody business that presents itself. Her solution ends up being not entirely unexpected, but—if you paid attention to the first half of the book and correctly forgot all preconceived notions of virtue and rightness and healthy relationships—it is no less bloodily satisfying.

Well, for me at least. People on Storygraph were not entirely prepared, and rated it accordingly. But not I! And now, dear reader, whom I hope I have prepared, not you, either. Taken on its own terms, this book is macabre and gruesome and psychologically rich and chewy and not the slightest bit healthy. A flourless chocolate cake, with a garnish of fresh blood.

Nerd coefficient: 8/10, well worth your time and attention.

Highlights:

  • Art deco setting
  • Psychoanalysis
  • Cryptids
  • Cannibalism

Reference: Mascarenhas, Kate. Hokey Pokey [Head of Zeus, 2022].

CLARA COHEN lives in Scotland in a creaky old building with pipes for gas lighting still lurking under her floorboards. She is an experimental linguist by profession, and calligrapher and Islamic geometric artist by vocation. During figure skating season she does blather on a bit about figure skating. She is on Mastodon at wandering.shop/@ergative or on Bluesky at https://bsky.app/profile/ergative-abs.bsky.social.

Monday, November 16, 2026

TV Review: VisionQuest

What is the MCU Phase 6, if not recycled ideas persevering?

One of the weaknesses in the almost-masterpiece that was WandaVision was its inability to admit that Wanda was the actual villain of the story. With Doctor Strange 2, the MCU finally mustered the honesty to address Wanda’s misdeeds, even if dropping a mountain on her was a less than elegant way to dispatch her, and came too close to the cliché of redemption via death. So let’s be clear: Wanda never paid for the mental torture of a whole town, and it would be a big mistake to bring her back to Team Good. But it’s already a revered tradition that comic book characters don’t stay dead, and for Disney there’s no such thing as having enough money, so Wanda is doomed to the same fate of the Eternals: to be taken out of the toy box every once in a while for another session of make-believe.

But first, the WandaVision sequel series VisionQuest has an even more questionable choice to play with: in the first episode, we discover that, even after dying in Infinity War (twice) and being rebuilt in WandaVision, the original Vision somehow has managed to keep the Ultron program hidden in his own electronic brain. Remember Ultron? The snarky killer robot who almost smashed a city-sized rock into the planet? Turns out he was not fully destroyed; he’s been Vision’s digital prisoner all this time. Let’s remember that this version of Vision still cares deeply about Wanda, and that Ultron’s actions led to the political dissolution of Wanda’s birth country and the death of her twin brother. Vision should be the last person to want to keep such a monster alive. Could it be that he’s gone sentimental, one robot lending a hand to another? Or does he seriously believe that Ultron can be reformed?

It has been noted many times that this era of Disney is marked by an irritating reluctance to let the Bad Guys be truly bad; note the attempts to empathize with evil or handwave it in Maleficent, Cruella, Mufasa, and Elio. There’s also the problem of Marvel Studios panicking about its impending post-Endgame drift away from cultural dominance, which has already led to the transparently desperate move of bringing Robert Downey Jr. back in another role. Retconning Ultron’s destruction allows VisionQuest to take advantage of James Spader’s reliably welcome charisma, which wasn’t put to enough use in Age of Ultron, but it also comes off as another instance of risk aversion. It’s not like Age of Ultron was particularly loved the first time, but it saves a lot of effort to revive an established villain, put him in a situation that would presumably lead to some measure of inner growth, and then refuse to let him grow or learn at all. That’s the worst blunder this show commits: it would have been problematic enough to ask viewers to empathize with a repentant mass murderer, but here we get an unrepentant mass murderer, and still we’re expected to care for his woes.

In VisionQuest, the rebuilt Vision is trying to blend in with humans and have a normal life while he sorts out the borrowed memories he gained in WandaVision. Ultron has grown bored of his virtual confinement, and evading Vision’s firewall, he secretly contacts a bounty hunter who has been hired by a secret party to capture Vision. At the same time, the memories and powers of Tommy Maximoff, one of the two fantasy children that Wanda conjured up in WandaVision, have reincarnated in a random guy from London who now has to decide whether he’ll embrace the identity that has invaded his mind. Also, a masked assassin has started hunting down the bosses of an AI company that designed the software that Tony Stark used in all his robots. These three plotlines establish Vision’s journey through the season: to resolve whether he’ll be a proper son to Ultron, a proper father to Tommy, and a proper person to himself.

To explore all these challenges, Vision has built a palace of the mind, a virtual home in his own head where he can have existential conversations with other Stark creatures, primarily JARVIS, EDITH and FRIDAY, but also the adorably cantankerous genocidal maniac Ultron. The scenes set in this imagined space have an air that resembles Herman’s Head, with funny props serving as shorthand for computer files and subprograms. The set design, decorated as a mid-20th-century house, is fun to look at, but could have been used even more creatively. Some of the visual metaphors, such as the recurrent image of a furnace overheating, are just too obvious.

While Vision tries to avoid capture, Ultron makes the acquaintance of another killer robot, played with masterful pathos by the always delightful T’Nia Miller. The scenes where the two villains exchange notes on misanthropy and eventually form a perverse alliance of sick, twisted romance are the best part of the show. The talents of Spader and Miller score multiple homeruns with the acting challenge that is this waltz of malicious intentions between their characters.

As for Paul Bettany, the acting challenge is that Vision is lying to himself. He has all the memories of his time with Wanda, plus the false memories of WandaVision, and he claims that he can’t bring himself to feel anything about it. This is an especially interesting problem for a nonhuman character to have, because the excuse is easy to believe. Vision tells himself that being a robot prevents him from properly mourning Wanda, but that ignores the fact that he has already loved her. Tommy’s problem is only superficially similar: he does have the imaginary child’s memories, but they’re not part of his personal history; they’re just grafted onto his consciousness, whereas Vision is wrestling with the death of a woman he really dated. For everything else that this show fails to execute properly, at least Vision manages in the end to acknowledge the pain he’s been denying.

Tommy’s arc is, lamentably, hindered by narrative necessity. Superspeed is one of those powers that can instantly break a story (which is why stories involving Superman so often choose to forget he has it), so each episode of VisionQuest needs to come up with a contrived reason why he can’t just solve the entire plot on his own. Since he doesn’t have much else going on, he’s reduced from a full character to a plot device, a stepstone in Vision’s development.

And then we get to what the show believes is its ace card, but is actually a nothingburger: the whole Ultron situation. It would be too easy to claim links between this plot and the real-world problem of slopware invading our lives, but the show doesn’t find anything of relevance to say on the matter (not the least because real-world slopware is not, in fact, conscious). Ultron starts and ends the season as a bitter human-hater who is a fleeting moment of caprice away from killing everyone. The final episode has Vision putting Ultron through hundreds of iterations of his own subjective WandaVision to give him the space he needs in order to process a newfound grief, but what eventually convinces Ultron to spare humankind isn’t a moment of moral realization, but of exhaustion. The scene with the key turning point wants to say that Vision finally reached Ultron by showing him there was someone who cared about him, but the fact that they share similar experiences of personal loss can’t even remotely outweigh Ultron’s attempts to eradicate humans (twice). There’s no believable reason why Vision should care for Ultron, nor should we either.

VisionQuest has worthy ideas to explore, but the need to keep certain characters available for future entries works against any moral conclusion the story might have been working towards, and more specifically, it’s a point against Vision’s character that he chose to keep Ultron alive. Regardless of how much enjoyment we get from watching James Spader throw snark, we didn’t need to return to Ultron. Star Wars may have tried to convince us otherwise, but redeeming genocidal maniacs is not clever storytelling. Marvel Studios needs to find new ideas, urgently.

Nerd Coefficient: 5/10.

POSTED BY: Arturo Serrano, multiclass Trekkie/Whovian/Moonie/Miraculer, accumulating experience points for still more obsessions.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Book Review: The Quantum Dawn, by Derek Künsken

Are you sure we start here?

The Quantum Dawn | Book by Derek Künsken | Official Publisher Page ...
cover artist: Justin Adams

Solaris, The Quantum Dawn’s publisher, do a neat line in high concept SF. It’s the kind of SF that makes your brain work and can be colourful, slightly anarchic and definitely feel like the concepts are as important as the characters and the plot. That works brilliantly for me because I love SF that grapples with actual ideas about how the world might be – not just looking at how people might organise themselves but deeper than that.

 

The Quantum Dawn is Derek Künsken’s fourth entry into this series but don’t let you put that off. It starts with The Quantum Magician and continue from there, slated to wrap up with the fifth in the series coming next year (2027) called The Quantum Temple.

 

I really loved the first three and let this review act as a recommendation to get out there and try them if you haven’t. If you liked The Three Body Problem or better still (and another Solaris alumnus) Yoon Ha Lee’s Nine Fox Gambit, then this is going to be for you too.

 

Without spoilering the story, book three actually closed nearly all the plot threads down nicely and left us with an outcome that felt satisfying and, crucially, not really in need of more in the series.

 

So when I heard that Künsken was creating not just one but two more I was pretty excited but also wondered where this story was going to go.

 

Having read Quantum Dawn I think it’s safe to say that you could stop at the end of the opening trilogy of books and not feel the need to continue on – the story that Künsken’s telling in Quantum Dawn is, effectively, sequel/follow on but it’s also quite different both in feel and in content.

 

Because at its heart The Quantum Dawn is a time travel novel in the fashion of the 2004 movie Primer which remains the only time travel movie to get the science right (for a given category of right). It’s also why I hate time travel stories because nearly every single one I’ve ever encountered is ponk – not understanding its own nature and the questions the concept demands or using as a shorthand for resolution or roadblocked plot or, worse still, failing to lean into the weirdness that using time as an extendable axis alongside depth, breadth and length really implies.

 

There’s a lot of techno-babble in this story and that is definitely where it can fall down because alongside that babble is a lot of repetition – where terms and situations are repeatedly explained for the reader. I can understand the need to make some of the weirdness clearer for the amateur (my doctorate is in theoretical physics so I am trying to be careful when reading it, assuming others won’t bring that same background expertise to the bit). However, these repetitions absolutely break the pacing of a story that is, at its heart, a very long shaggy dog story about returning to our beginnings.

 

There are some great ideas here (and this is one of Künsken’s strengths), not least the Fermi Paradox, how time travel might be possible, how the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics sees time, the nature of consciousness and how that might or might not be essential to sentience (and vice versa) but I felt like I was wallowing too much in explaining how these worked rather than showing it. Especially as we’re four books in.

 

Having said that, this is the first time that the world Künsken’s built seriously leans into the time travel he built into earlier entries and if there’s elements in here of loops and recursion, of avoiding yourself in the past and so on this is, effectively, quite new in terms of scale and the stakes in play. It’s also interesting how he plays with identity and the nature of self in this – not so much as meeting yourself going back and coming forwards but in how different version of the same self might see the world entirely differently – an open exploration of nature vs nurture without labouring over whether an individual is one or the other.

 

As this is the first of what is essentially a sequel duology, Künsken spends a lot of time moving his pieces into place which, largely, works but at the same time it’s clear this novel got out of hand and it needs, from my perspective as a reader, a really heavy edit to remove the repetition and techno-babble. I think it probably also needs a second go that has an eye on the ‘there’s a lot going on but nothing’s actually happening,’ that I felt towards the end of the story.

 

In particular because this is a time travel road trip that road trip needs to feel like we’re moving along but a couple of times too many I felt that I’d encountered exactly this part of the conflict before and while time loops are fun, linear encounters that don’t really deliver much beyond repetition can drag.

 

It’s a personal thing but I like to feel that even in the middle of the series that when I’ve picked up a story I get a beginning and end regardless of everything else going on. Part of that’s just wanting the last book now, I guess.

Overall then, I enjoyed this and although I wasn’t as enraptured as I was expecting I’m happily waiting for the final entry in the series to see what happens to Bel, Cas, Stills, St. Matthew and the others.


--

The Math


Highlights:

  • Exciting time travel and hard science shenanigans
  • Super weird aliens
Nerd coefficient: 5/10

Reference: Derek Künsken, The Quantum Dawn [Solaris, 2026]

STEWART HOTSTON is an author of all kinds of science fiction and fantasy. He's also a keen Larper (he owns the UK Fest system, Curious Pastimes). He's a sometime physicist and currently a banker in the City of London. A Subjective Chaos, BSFA and BFA finalist he's also Chair of the British Science Fiction Association and Treasurer for the British Fantasy Society. He is on bluesky at: @stewarthotston.com.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Anime Review: Though I Am an Inept Villainess: Cour One

Magic, vengeance, palace drama, and humor 


Sometimes life seems better on the other side. One person is showered with affection and praise while another drowns in cruelty and bitterness. But what is life really like for the person of whom you are jealous? And how do you navigate these deep thoughts while also dealing with a murder plot and lots of palace intrigue. It’s been a long wait for the return of The Apothecary Diaries. In the meantime, an anime with a very similar historical setting but much lighter tone has arrived to fill the gap. Though I Am An Inept Villainess, is based on a popular light novel series and tells the story of two women, one kind, one bitter, who are each suffering in different ways. But things get complicated when a forbidden spell causes them to switch bodies with unexpected results. The story has the familiar vibes of The Goose Girl fairy tale, but with an optimistic, humorous, and ironic take on life switching.

Though I Am An Inept Villainess, is set in a magical, ancient China-like setting where the imperial palace houses numerous consorts, concubines, and selected maidens from noble families who are there for the emperor and his family. Reirin is a beautiful and kind maiden from the Kou clan. Her beauty and sweet personality make her a favorite of the handsome young crown prince Gyoumei. Her assigned villa is lavish, her attendants fawn over her, and she is referred to as the court’s beautiful “butterfly”. Meanwhile Keigetsu is the designated maiden of the Shu clan. She is despised and mistreated because the other maidens and consorts deem her unworthy, despite the fact that she is related to the respected, polite and reserved noble consort, Shu Gabi. The bullying Keigetsu suffers in the palace fuels her anger causing her to be rude and bitter, which further ostracizes her. In frustration, Keigetsu uses illegal magic to swap bodies with the beautiful Reirin while attempting to injure her in front of a crowd of court ladies and the crown prince. Reirin’s body is saved with Keigetsu in possession of it. Meanwhile Reirin is trapped in Keigetsu’s body and sentenced to a harsh trial for attempting to hurt Reirin. Keigetsu is initially thrilled to be pampered and fawned over but she soon discovers that Reirin’s body is actually sick and frail and in constant pain, despite her sunny disposition. Reirin, on the other hand, is subjected to hatred and cruelty as a consequence of being trapped in Keigetsu’s body, and the curse prevents her from telling anyone the truth about the body swap. But instead of being despondent, Reirin is thrilled to have a healthy body and to be able to eat what she wants and to be physically active. Even when she is demoted to a run down, damaged villa, she eagerly accepts it and works hard to patch it up and dig a vegetable garden to grow her own food. In Keigetsu’s body she only has one surly attendant, Leelee, who openly despises her and even tries to hurt her due to the original Keigetsu’s mistreatment of her. But Reirin’s persistent natural cheerfulness and Keigetsu’s inevitable grouchiness eventually cause those close to them to notice that something isn’t right with the two maidens. Beyond that, a larger scheme of palace intrigue and a revenge murder plot force the two women to work together to solve the larger mystery.

While the series has many overlapping elements with The Apothecary Diaries, including court intrigue, murder mysteries, and an imperial harem setting, Though I Am An Inept Villainess has a much lighter tone. The earlier episodes are particularly humorous with Reirin’s relentless optimism leaving everyone perplexed and the audience amused. The series is almost entirely female focused with most of the intrigue happening among the women. The serious and earnest crown prince Gyumei is aided in his oversight of the palace by his sharp and cynical younger half-brother Shin-U. The two are the only men who appear regularly and a brief flashback offers some interesting insight into the power imbalance in their relationship. The girl-power vibe is ironic in such a setting. The shows does a nice job of telling parallel tales of jealousy, sisterhood, revenge, and reconciliation among different generations in the imperial household. Those themes resonate as Reirin and Keigetsu navigate their response to different types of trauma as well as the relentless pressure of societal expectations.

Overall, Though I Am An Inept Villainess delivers lighthearted storytelling with humor and just enough intrigue and personality drama to keep viewers hooked. While not as perfectly crafted as The Apothecary Diaries, the series offers solid entertainment and unexpectedly complex characters in an unexpectedly complicated world.

--

The Math

Nerd Coefficient: 7/10

Highlights:
  • Fantasy fairy tale vibes
  • Light comedy and cuteness
  • Sweet messaging
POSTED BY: Ann Michelle Harris – Multitasking, fiction writing Trekkie currently dreaming of her next beach vacation.