More horror, less Christmas in the latest adaptation of the Dickens classic
Some stories are eternal, not just in a philosophical sense but in a practical, movie industry, goldmine sense. Much like Romeo and Juliet and Cinderella, A Christmas Carol is the kind of story that has countless adaptations, almost such that it’s become a genre unto itself. The approach to the story and the style of each adaptation becomes a reflection of its society. In keeping with the recent trends for smart horror, the latest adaptation of A Christmas Carol is Ebenezer, a film that is more creepy horror and less colorful cozy Christmas. With leading actors like Johnny Depp and Trammell Tillman, that edginess should be no surprise.
Ebenezer tells the classic story of Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp), who is running his financial business alone after the death of his partner Marley (Ian McKellan) seven years ago. He is aided in his work by his hardworking clerk, Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint), whom he mistreats and underpays. Cratchit is struggling to support his wife (Charlie Murphy) and children, including his terminally ill youngest child (Freddie Lee-Grey). Scrooge scoffs at efforts to help the poor and ignores the request of his nephew Fred (Sam Claflin) for Scrooge to spend time with Fred and his wife Clara (Daisy Ridley). On Christmas Eve, Scrooge is visited by the ghost of his old partner Marley, who warns him to change his ways and tells Scrooge of the impending visits of the ghosts of Christmas past (Andrea Riseborough), present (Trammell Tillman), and future. Through the course of the night, each ghost takes Ebenezer on a tour of his life and the lives of those he neglects. Seeing the troubled course of his life and seeing the suffering of others helps to teach him a lesson in kindness.
Instead of opulent Victorian Christmas scenes, Ebenezer takes a deep dive into the macabre, both through the supernatural and also through the horror of real-world neglect and poverty. More than other adaptations, Ebenezer spends time pondering extreme poverty in a world where the poorest are forced into prisons and workhouses. The opening credits montage alternates between scenes of the wealthy and scenes of the poor in complementary situations. Many adaptations of the story mention the existence of workhouses, but this one actually spends time there, painting them in the same grim, gray melancholy as the ghost-filled graveyard scenes.
Another unexpected element is the film’s decidedly supernatural tone. I’ve watched several other versions of this story, and this one is very horror forward. The palette is gray and dark. The buildings are creepy and gothic. But beyond that, there are direct horror elements, including throngs of zombie-like ghosts coming after Ebenezer. At one point he gets sucked into his bed in a scene reminiscent of the only Nightmare on Elm Street film I’ve watched. In other versions of this story, the ghosts of Christmas past and present are portrayed as essentially (although eccentrically) human, but in this film, they are quite creepy and inhuman despite the fact that they were once, tragically, regular people. Bill Murray’s 1988 version of the story, Scrooged, had some extreme horror special effects but was balanced by equally extreme humor. Ebenezer mostly stays grim and serious rather than veering into true comedy.
Ebenezer benefits from the built-in witty banter it takes from the original text. However, the awkward attempts at physical humor were my least favorite parts of the film. The strange choices were unsettling. In some ways they added to the overall feeling of dread rather than offering a counterbalancing lightness. Of course, that kind of strange humor is perfect for an actor like Johnny Depp. Unlike other versions of Ebenezer Scrooge, his interpretation feels more quirky and eccentric rather than just grumpy and stingy, and the result is jarringly unhinged. In addition to elements of horror, the film adds unexpected cynicism. Some of the traditionally honorable side characters are portrayed as hypocritical con artists. Even a beggar in an early scene turns out not to be what he seems to be. The message seems to be that trust is elusive, even as we strive to do better. All this bleakness somewhat dampens the film’s emotional intensity. But in the scenes where it does connect, the effect is solid.
Ebenezer closely tracks the story beats and even some of the dialogue of the original text, but it periodically diverges from it in unexpected ways. Part of the fun of watching a retelling is knowing generally what will happen next but being surprised at the execution. In Ebenezer there are enough small changes that you start to have a feeling of uncertainty, although the primary story beats remain the same. One interesting divergence from the usual interpretations is the spirits themselves. Normally, they are portrayed as sort of like angels with a job to educate. However, in Ebenezer the three spirits (past, present, and future) are noted to be formerly real living people who are now doing penance in their death for their own shortcomings in life. This adds some unexpected poignancy and creepiness to the story.
Overall, the tone of Ebenezer is closer to quirky stories like Widow’s Bay, offering grimness and horror as a way to process difficult realities. This style may not work for those looking for big Christmas trees and happily singing children. Despite its general faithfulness to the original story, Ebenezer is a grim departure from the usual optimism, and offers an edgier version of Scrooge for a new generation of viewers.
Nerd Coefficient: 7/10.
Highlights:
- More horror, less Christmas
- Strange humor
- Edgier, cynical storytelling
POSTED BY: Ann Michelle Harris – Multitasking, fiction writing Trekkie currently dreaming of her next beach vacation.





