‘80s nostalgia will ruin your life
A barely hidden tragedy lurks inside every cute adventure involving children. Once you’ve saved the hidden fantasy kingdom, or helped the stranded fairy/mermaid/unicorn find its way back home, or rescued the lost princess, or averted the death of magic, what next? How can mundane life possibly hope to compare? After having met elves and wizards and dragons, it must feel like a cosmic punishment to have to deal with job interviews and dentist appointments and taxes. You better hope the amount of excitement in your life doesn’t peak when you’re ten.
So consider poor Elliott at the end of E.T. What’s he going to do with the rest of his life, now that he’s had the most world-shaking experience in the history of the human species? What kind of man will he become? What will maintain his interest for long enough? The cruel truth is that, if he wants to have anything resembling a meaningful stay on Earth, the best thing he can do is forget about his alien friend.
In the Netflix movie Allen, the child who had an alien friend turns out to be unable to grow up. The break from reality is brief, but profound by a child’s standards: the alien and the human watch movies, eat junk food, play board games. But then, as always happens, the alien needs to return to its planet. And the child doesn’t take that well, not one bit. Entirely understandably, he spends the next decades of his life obsessed with recapturing the original spark that gave his life a fleeting sense of transcendence. He refuses to move out of his childhood home, just in case the alien decides to come back, and builds a makeshift radio to try to communicate with it. While the people around him are getting engaged and/or having kids, he remains stuck in a bygone time.
Although Allen is written and directed as a comedy, watching an adult willingly trap himself in a hopeless quest to stop time and feel like a child again is just sad. There are heart-rending moments in this movie when you can tell how completely that alien encounter messed him up: he sees no reason to take up any earthly pursuit because he’s genuinely convinced that this world has nothing to offer him.
Allen ought to serve as an antidote to ‘80s nostalgia. We’re living through a massive cultural whiplash in which some members of Generation X struggle with letting the past be past. The kids who grew up with Ghostbusters and He-Man and Star Wars and Top Gun and Mad Max and, yes, E.T. have become furiously possessive over the joys of their childhood, desperate to keep any future iteration of those stories feeling just like they felt the first time. No mature adult should want the Reagan years to come back, but nostalgia isn’t rational. Nostalgia is a coward’s refuge when reality takes effort.
In a twist that isn’t given enough time to fully deliver its punch, the alien in Allen does come back. The grownup human and his unchanged wrinkly gray pal immediately resume their unfinished business with amusement rides and cotton candy and karaoke, because that’s the limit of what our protagonist can imagine he can do with an emissary from another star: very human things he could have done with anyone else at any time. However, soon we learn that the alien isn’t on Earth for innocent reasons, and the second half of the movie shifts gears to a race against time to prevent a messy, horrifying, planet-wide, very yucky catastrophe. Turns out ‘80s nostalgia can kill you, literally.
Allen is a story that knows how to perform at the scale of its modest ambitions. It shouldn’t be a big revelation that all children need to grow up. It shouldn’t take a tongue-in-cheek deconstruction of one of the most cherished classics of cinema to explain why time can’t go back. But will the former kids listen? It must still be possible to reach some, to save some. Don’t lament the past that went by, that no longer exists and can’t hear you. Lament the present that isn’t being lived.
Nerd Coefficient: 7/10.
POSTED BY: Arturo Serrano, multiclass Trekkie/Whovian/Moonie/Miraculer, accumulating experience points for still more obsessions.





